The Student News Site of Trinity University

Trinitonian

The Student News Site of Trinity University

Trinitonian

The Student News Site of Trinity University

Trinitonian

Health care in America is high cost, poor quality

A look into the horrors of the treatment and costs in the American health care system
Health+care+in+America+is+high+cost%2C+poor+quality

Health care in this country sucks. Insurance rates are prohibitively high, making quality care inaccessible. Although programs such as Medicare, Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act have decreased the uninsured population, 26 million Americans remain uninsured. This exacerbates socioeconomic disparities and secures the United States a spot at the bottom of the list for quality, reasonably-priced health care in high-income countries.

The United States spends far more than comparable countries such as Canada, New Zealand, the U.K. and France on health care. Specifically, private and out-of-pocket spending is significantly higher, with private spending being five times that of Canada and out-of-pocket spending over twice that of France and New Zealand. This nightmarish level of spending for access to necessary medical attention is cruel and unusual, to say the least.

These high costs cause many Americans to seek medical care less often than they should, waiting for conditions to worsen before getting help. Not everyone can afford to spend precious dollars on investigating a nagging cough. Money should not be a barrier to receiving necessary care.

Despite high rates of spending, health outcomes in the U.S. are among the worst. The United States has the highest rate of preventable deaths, suicide, obesity and chronic disease among member countries of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). Unfortunately, it isn’t shocking to add the lowest life expectancy and highest rate of hospitalization for preventable diseases to this list as well. Getting the least bang for your buck is the name of the game in American health care.

These statistics concern mainly white Americans. For African Americans, the numbers are even worse. The uninsured rate for African Americans is almost double that of white Americans, and average spending on health care premiums is almost 20% of the typical household income as opposed to 11% for the average American. Infant and maternal mortality rates are also doubled as compared to whites. The reason behind this comes down to high poverty leading to decreased health care access. Not only are doctor visits unaffordable, but in poverty-stricken areas they are hard to physically come by.

17.1% of African Americans live in poverty while only 8.6% of white Americans are impoverished. This is likely a result of lower education rates in African Americans leading to lower income levels. Unsurprisingly, this correlates with less money to spend on doctor visits and an inability to live in wealthy areas where quality healthcare is readily available.

Clearly, priorities are out of whack when it comes to allocating medical services. Those who need it most have the least access, and oftentimes the system values profitability over saving lives. Doctors are incentivized by high pay to become highly specialized and treat advanced-stage diseases rather than simple nutrition, exercise and primary care that would prove far more practical. Drugs and quick fixes are repeatedly pushed onto patients when simple and equally effective alternatives are available. It is more profitable to keep the public reliant on medication than anything else.

Furthermore, prior authorization policies keep many from being seen by a doctor altogether. Even for insured Americans, not everyone has access to every health care facility. If a certain doctor’s office does not take your insurance, you can be barred from being seen altogether. Someone could walk into urgent care with a broken leg and be sent right back home with no treatment. I’ve seen it happen.

Working at an urgent care, I have seen people turned away for not having certain paperwork or not owning the right insurance to be seen by the facility. People with clearly swollen arms or legs, breaking down in tears from the pain they are experiencing have been told, “there’s nothing we can do.”

Fixing these problems requires a major reform in every facet of the healthcare industry. Some good places to start would be expanding public health insurance to cover the entire population, investing in mobile clinics to cater to underserved areas and incentivizing doctors to do what’s best for their patients without worrying about their pay or job security. As it stands, this system benefits nobody except those who stand to line their pockets from the suffering of others.

View Comments (5)
More to Discover
About the Contributor
Riya Vankamamidi
Riya Vankamamidi, Opinion Columnist
Hello! My name is Riya Vankamamidi (she/her) and I am an Opinion Columnist here at the Trinitonian. I am a sophomore Psychology major and Biology minor on the pre-med track. I love to bake, crochet and meet new people so if you ever see me around campus, come say hi!

Comments (5)

All Trinitonian Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • E

    EdithMar 27, 2024 at 6:28 am

    Medicare Sucks.
    A Advantage plan is sicker.
    Yes United Health Care made 22 billion dollars last year profit.
    I could not get a med I needed or a procedure.
    I canceled Medicare and my Advantafe plan.
    They are a scam..

    Reply
  • L

    Linda A McDonaldMar 26, 2024 at 1:39 pm

    Tell me about it. My mother died due to medical negligence in hospital. She was misdiagnosed, operated on, went into a coma and never returned. She was 62. She had Medicaid.

    Reply
  • J

    Joanne ArduinMar 26, 2024 at 12:29 pm

    Agree strongly with your opinion. I recently retired from Healthcare. I worked for over 25 years as an NP and sadly witnessed the transformation of Healthcare into big business. Private equity and venture capitalits taking over and insurance companies making billions in profits. Tragic.

    Reply
  • S

    SCMar 25, 2024 at 11:16 pm

    You’re right, the US healthcare system is a huge, expensive, dysfunctional mess. Insurance companies have way too much authority in determining what care is/is not provided.
    Everyone involved (staff, facilities, suppliers, insurance companies etc) gets paid but patient outcomes are sub par. Where is the accountability for poor quality of care provided?
    Insurance, deductibles and copays are obscenely expensive for most of us, especially compared to the disease ridden state of “health” most Americans experience.
    Most providers are part of large, greedy businesses focused on profits over truly healthy customers/patients.
    The American healthcare system needs a major overhaul. Way too much $ for unacceptable results.

    Reply
  • H

    HeheMar 25, 2024 at 8:43 pm

    They can go to the emergencies in the hospital they never turn back anyone with or without insurance.

    Reply